Our Licensed Brokers and Staff

Tom HenningerTom Henninger is the second generation owner and current President having purchased his father’s business in 1997. Tom is triple licenced, with RIBO for car, house, and business insurance, with FSCO for life insurance products and as an Investment Funds advisor with Manulife Securities Investment Services Inc. 

Tom has lived in Oshawa since Grade 1, is happily married to Holly since 1990, has two great kids,  loves reading, spending time with family and friends, especially at their cottage in the Muskoka’s and together with the team at Henninger Insurance loves helping clients with their insurance needs.

Email Tom

Grace MccullochGrace is a licenced insurance broker since 1999 with over 26 years of experience in the customer service industry.  She was born in Newfoundland but moved to Oshawa in 1970.  Happily married to Glen since 1988 and has two sons that have always been the centre of her life.  

She enjoys spending time at the family cottage or working at home in her flower garden and is always excited about curling up with a good book. Henninger Insurance provides the perfect team environment for her to excel in her organizational skills and passion for helping people.

Email Grace

Creighton HastingsCreighton Hastings has been a broker with Henninger Insurance for 14 years and licenced with 25 years of experience. Along with personal and commercial lines insurance, Creighton is also life insurance licenced with expertise in company group benefits and life insurance. Employment history includes Prudential Insurance, Liberty Mutual, and Hollis Wealth insurance over the years.

Creighton enjoys the challenge of advising and offering solutions to new and existing clients with their personal and business insurance. He continues to keep his skills current by taking continuing education courses relevant to the changing marketplace of the insurance industry. He lives in the Port Perry area and loves spending time at his place up north, fishing & entertaining.

Email Creighton